Taft Wins Complete Defense Verdict in $3.6 Million Waterfront Property Dispute

 

Taft attorneys secured a complete defense verdict for clients following a six-day jury trial in Martin County, Florida. The case involved the Plaintiff’s claim that our clients sold her a waterfront home for $4 million but failed to disclose significant latent defects. Plaintiff claimed $3.6 million in damages and entitlement to punitive damages. After a compelling closing argument by lead attorney Gregory Weiss, the jury found for our clients on all four counts and awarded no damages.

The Defendants sold Plaintiff, Amanda Cerny, their waterfront home in early 2022. Cerny later alleged the sellers failed to disclose water intrusion caused by hidden defects. Before filing suit, however, Cerny had submitted an insurance claim attributing the water intrusion to a storm and wind-driven rain.

At trial, the plaintiff’s expert testified that a complete absence of waterproofing and flashing behind the home’s stone façade allowed the water intrusion. Cross-examination highlighted that the expert had neither removed any portion of the façade to visually confirm his opinion nor performed testing to substantiate it. The plaintiff sought $3.6 million to remove and replace the façade, install waterproofing and flashing, and complete other repairs, along with punitive damages.

The jury rejected all four claims – failure to disclose, breach of warranty, fraud in the inducement, and negligent misrepresentation – returning a complete victory for the sellers. The Taft trial team was led by partner Gregory Weiss and counsel Robert Kraus, with support from the firm’s paralegals and professionals, including the appellate team.

In This Article

You May Also Like