Jessica A. Mager


Jessica's practice is focused in the family law area. She routinely represents clients in all aspects of domestic relations litigation, including complex divorce with an emphasis in child custody matters, establishment and enforcement of child and spousal support, establishment of paternity, and general civil litigation.

In 2017, Jessica was appointed to Taft's Gender Advancement Committee. She leads the Columbus office efforts and gender equality initiatives, which are meant to strengthen Taft’s role in the Columbus community as a leader for women. In 2021, Taft was among only 50 law firms recognized by Seramount (formerly Working Mother Media) as one of the “Best Law Firms for Women.” This is the second consecutive year Taft has made the list, which recognizes firms that utilize best practices in recruiting, retaining, promoting, and developing women lawyers. Jessica is active in the office's Support Her Endeavors campaign, which was initiated by honoring the female founder of Columbus restaurant Lindey’s. Jessica is also a member of Taft's Modern Workplace Task Force.

Jessica is AV Preeminent Peer Review rated by Martindale-Hubbell. She is recognized by Ohio Super Lawyers as a Rising Star in Family Law. Columbus CEO magazine honored Jessica as a “Top Lawyer for Private Client Law” in 2019 and as a “Top Lawyer for Divorce Law” in 2021.

Jessica plays a major role in supporting the introduction of HB 226 in Ohio, legislation that would increase protections for court-appointed advocates. The bill would make it a first-degree misdemeanor for someone to abuse, threaten, or harass guardians ad litem or a court-appointed special advocate in carrying out their court-mandated duties, ultimately protecting those who advocate for the community’s most vulnerable citizens.

In addition to Ohio, Jessica is also licensed to practice in Federal Court in the Southern District of California.

Other Professional Experience

  • Attorney, Nazimova & Davis, San Diego, California, 2002 – 2005
  • Capital University Law School, Columbus, Ohio
    • Host Committee Member, National Center for Adoption Law & Policy, Autumn Wine Celebration, 2007 –  2012
    • Staff Attorney, Child and Family Advocacy Program, funded by the Columbus Coalition Against Family Violence, 2001 – 2002
  • Child Welfare Caseworker, Intake and Investigations, Franklin County Children Services, Columbus, Ohio, 1996-2001


  • AV Peer Review Rated (Preeminent), LexisNexis/Martindale-Hubbell

  • Honoree, Columbus CEO “Top Lawyers,” Divorce Law (2021)

  • Honoree, Columbus CEO “Top Lawyers,” Private Client (2019)

  • Honoree, Ohio Super Lawyers Rising Stars (2007, 2009 - 2013)

  • Young Alumnus of the Year Honoree, Capital University Law School (2007)

All Service Areas


  • Capital University Law School (2001)
  • Bowling Green State University, B.S. in Criminal Justice (1996)


  • Federal - U.S. Supreme Court
  • Federal - Southern District of Ohio
  • State - Ohio
  • State - California
  • Federal - Southern District of California

Notable Matters

  • Successfully represented the Harvest Wind HOA in a zoning appeal before the Genoa Township Board of Zoning.
  • Represented national business owner in divorce with significant separate property assets as well as joint marital assets.
  • Represented parent in regaining custody of a child from an Emergency Ex Parte Custody Order.
  • Represented a client’s former spouse in child support modification through trial, objections through final judgment.
  • Represented small business owner in contested divorce and in contingency litigation initiated by lending institution for recovery of deficiency judgment against parties of divorce.
  • Represented never married parents in establishment of shared parenting plan for child of the parties.

Speeches and Publications

  • Presenter and Coordinator: Columbus Bar Association CLE seminar, “It’s All About the Relocation: Attorney, GAL, and Judicial Roles," Nov. 4, 2016
  • Presenter: Columbus Bar Association CLE seminar, "Family Law and the Military Child: Divorce, Custody and Visitation Issues," Nov. 11, 2015
  • Actor in Training Materials: Chester Professionalism Institute, “Dealing with Problem Clients, Counsel & Judges: A Practical and Ethical Approach to Litigation,” Oct. 30, 2015
  • Presenter and Coordinator: Columbus Bar Association CLE Seminar, "What Makes a Guardian Ad Litem Tick?" May 13, 2015
  • Author: “Fear of Financial Hardship: How the Economy Impacts Divorce,” CWS Newsletter, Vol. 2, 2009. Also published in Columbus CEO, July 2009
  • “Social Security Benefits Clarified by the Supreme Court,” co-authored with Eugene B. Lewis, Columbus Bar Briefs, Spring 2005

Professional Affiliations

  • AV Peer Review Rating (LexisNexis/Martindale-Hubbell)


  • Women Lawyers of Franklin County


  • Columbus Bar Association

    Member, Judicial Screening Committee
    Member, Admissions Committee
    Member, Family Law Committee
    Member, Barrister Leadership Program
    Member, Pro Bono Task Force
    Team Captain, Rock-N-Bowl, Taft Stettinius & Hollister LLP (fifth year)
    Member, 2019 Nominations Committee

  • Delaware County Bar Association

    State of Ohio Mock Trial Judge

  • Columbus Bar Foundation

    "All in One Campaign" in support of the Legal Aid Society of Columbus

  • Women Economic Leadership Development (W.E.L.D.)


Community Involvement

  • Alcott Elementary PTA

    Committee Chair
    Member, Cultural Inclusion & Awareness Board

  • American Red Cross


  • Delaware County Humane Society


  • Pro Bono Attorney - Franklin County


  • St. Paul Catholic Church

    Member, Building Fund
    Fourth Grade and Sixth Grade Catechist
    Seventh Grade Boys Basketball Volunteer

  • The Goddard School

    Classroom Volunteer

  • Westerville Amateur Soccer Association

    Head Girls Soccer Coach

  • CHOICES for Domestic Violence

    Sponsor, Peacemaker Awards Luncheon

  • Girls on the Run Coach
  • Legal Aid Tenant Advocacy Project Volunteer
  • Nationwide Children's Hospital Columbus 1/2 Marathon 2019


  • Genoa Middle School Glow Run 2020

    Participant and Volunteer
    Top 10 Finisher